
Warning: the following post should, in all honesty, be three posts. You may want to grab your favorite beverage and a comfy chair before beginning.
Why E-Books?I should preface this post by mentioning something my readers may not know about me: I love technology. Given the content of this blog, that may come as a surprise to those of you who don't know me in real life. Yet, in spite of my love for art, travel, and romance novels, my degrees are in engineering and I've worked IT on and off for years.
Having admitted my love for all things wired, I have to admit one thing: I really, really hate the idea of e-books. There's just something about the oft-cited "dead tree book" -- the smell of ink, the feel of the paper, the sound of the pages as they turn. Reading a book is, above all, a sensual experience that one cannot replicate with files and machines.
That being said, over the past year, I have begun to realize the practicality of e-books. This process began as I moved into my current set of rooms, my little 250 square foot refuge from the world outside. Of course, at least 40 of those square feet are occupied by various book-holding devices -- an entire wall of them in my living room, with another half-wall in my bedroom. Some of these books -- particularly those devoted to art, with their glossy prints of paintings and buildings -- I simply cannot regret buying and owning. The presence of certain others, however, has begun to grate on me. I love mass-market paperbacks, be they romance or mystery, and will staunchly defend them to any literary snob, any time. Yet, I find the sensual experience of reading these to be largely identical from one to another -- the same inks, the same papers, the same sounds. Though I continue to enjoy them, I have ceased to enjoy the taunting presence of dozens of them, all over my room. Yet, I enjoy reading and re-reading them too much to simply check them out from my local library -- which, it must be said, is sorely lacking in these genres as it is.
Another element of my growing curiosity regarding e-books has been my travel habits. An avid reader since the age of five, I find it impossible to go
anywhere -- be it the grocery store or Italy -- without at least one book. If this travel involves the crossing of state lines (or any hotel or hospital stay), I take at least five. For international trips, nothing less than ten will do. Do I always read all of the books I bring? No, but as any reader will tell you, not every book will do for every mood, and I like to be prepared. Of course, towing ten books along on an airplane is by no means easy or convenient, and I can't count the number of pulled muscles and aching backs I've had thanks to a carry-on laden with pound upon pound of books. As the frequency of my travel increases, the prospect of spending eternity with a bag full of books becomes more and more foreboding.
Finally, there's the issue of business travel. While carting around bags full of books is bad enough, it becomes even worse when traveling with one's boss and co-workers. Imagine the scene now: I sit down on a train, across from The Advisor and His Lovely Wife. As we get settled in, we each pull out our reading material for the journey. TA has several journal articles. HLW pulls out Team of Rivals. And M? M pulls out Her Master and Commander, or perhaps The Viscount Who Loved Me, complete with the requisite cover clinch. Hell, even if M pulls out a very appropriate journal for work, just digging through those books to get to it can be embarrassing. Now, I will defend my reading of romance and the genre as a whole until I am blue in the face, but there are some situations in which you simply don't want to explain yourself and your reading selection. With an e-book, TA and HLW can't tell if I'm reading the Journal of Cultural Heritage or Phyllida and the Brotherhood of Phillander.
Kindle vs. SonyWith these reasons in mind, I decided a few months ago that this would be the year of the e-book reader. Resigning myself to losing the sensations of book reading, I began to explore the different types of readers on the market. As most people who have explored the subject know, there are currently two big players in the e-book reader market: Sony and Amazon. Though other readers are out there (see the
Cool-er, the
Cybook, and others), none have been so well tested, poked, prodded, and reviewed by both media and consumers alike as
Sony's PRS-700 and
Amazon's Kindle 2
(Those familiar with Amazon's product line may wonder why I don't mention their recently released
Kindle DX
. The fact is, the Kindle itself is almost too thin for me; the same thickness with three times the surface area strikes me as ridiculous. Not to mention, who wants to find room in their purse for an electronic item the size of a piece of paper?)
My greatest frustration in making the decision between these two devices was that it is nearly impossible to see one in person before purchasing it. The PRS-700 can occasionally be found in stores (I was luckiest with Target) and Amazon has a
community devoted to seeing Kindles in your area, but in both cases it takes more effort than I would like. As a result, I worked almost exclusively from YouTube videos, reviews and user comments when making my decision.
When looking at the PRS-700, its benefits seem readily apparent: thin but not
too thin, few moving parts, and built-in LED lighting are all aspects of its design which initially impressed me. In fact, at one point, the PRS-700 was my clear frontrunner. Then I began examining it more closely. Constructed of aluminum (as opposed to the Kindle's white plastic), the PRS-700 is considerably more prone to dings and dents. Additionally, the feel of cold metal is NOT a sensation I enjoy while reading a book. Furthermore, the Sony software is not offered on Mac, a pet peeve of mine when it comes to Sony products in general. YouTube videos also revealed that the "advantageous" lights in fact created so much glare as to make them an annoyance.
With the Kindle, I was first aware of the disadvantages. To begin with, I have recently taken issue with some of Amazon's business practices, making me uncertain about supporting the company. I was also somewhat disturbed at the idea of locking myself into purchasing books from one vendor for the rest of my days. Finally, there was the fact that I rather agreed with the Smart Bitches: Kindle 2 resembles nothing so much as a delicate piece of matzoh. However, my further investigations in this case revealed the advantages of the device. It turned out that transferring documents and non-Amazon e-books was, in fact, fairly simple, and would take no more software than what I would have to install to simply
run the Sony machine on my Macs. Additionally, transferring these documents could be done free of charge with my USB cable. Though this is not necessarily an advantage over the Sony, I feel it is something that many people don't realize when considering the two options. Additionally, the documents can be transferred using Amazon's Whispernet 3G wireless for $0.10 each. This
is a clear advantage over the Sony, which has no wireless capabilities whatsoever.
However, the wireless advantages don't stop there. The main method of purchasing books from Amazon is, in fact, by browsing the wireless Kindle store, though they may also be purchased from a computer and sent to the device. Thus, with the Kindle, you can be sitting on the tarmac, waiting for your plane to take off, suddenly remember that Eloisa James's
This Duchess of Mine
was just released, and be reading it within 30 seconds. Though this sort of instant gratification is dangerous, it can only be seen as an advantage. As a result, even when traveling without a laptop, I still have access to the entire selection of Amazon books, magazines, and newspapers. If you're unsure whether a certain book is, in fact, the one you're looking for, you can also have Amazon send you a free sample chapter before you make your decision.
Love, at Long LastAs I'm sure you can tell from the picture on this post and the previous paragraphs, I went with the Kindle 2. Choosing Amazon's flat-rate $3.99 one-day shipping, I went home and began purchasing e-books. A mere 17 hours later (again with the instant gratification, Amazon?) I was holding the Kindle in my hands and the books I had purchased were already installed on the machine.
And, in spite of my reluctance to adopt e-books, I have to say...I love it. The best thing about the device is something I overlooked altogether during my shopping -- the e-paper screen. Thinking it was merely a way for Amazon and Sony to justify giving us a greyscale screen instead of a color LCD, I assumed it would be my least favorite thing about the device. Instead, it actually feels like you're reading a book -- I don't know how to describe this properly, but one look at an e-paper screen will convince you that this may be the best innovation to come to technology in a long time. In the form letter which accompanied the Kindle, Jeffrey Bezos (Amazon's founder), hoped I would be able to forget I was using the device and simply enjoy my reading. Between the lightness of the machine and the fascinating screen, I have to say this ended up being the case. If anything, I find reading on the Kindle to be less tiring to the eyes than reading a book -- certainly not true of LCD screens. Though I certainly will not stop buying "dead tree books", I feel that the Kindle will allow me to be more discerning with regards to which books deserve a place in my ever-so-small apartment.
Check back for updates about my first weeks with the Kindle -- and updates about real life, of course!